The holes seem gimmicky to me. Certainly not worth cutting your carpet for. Especially if you know that you have absolutely no intention of hosing out your Jeep - like most owners.
I am quite late to this thread but, I purchased the Quadratec branded ‘digital fit” mats made by weathertech. They even show up in a weathertech box. They save about $20 over the weathertech ones.
the green “quadratec” logo is ugly so I just ripped it off. No damage to the mat. And now no logo either.
Got the front and rear Bestop liners from Morris last week. Did the recommended mod to the label. Very happy with the way they turned out. Thanks to invertedlogic For the logos.