Jeepmojave85
Well-Known Member
I didn’t know my gladiator was rated so well, I love my Mojave and it’s been a blast to drive for the past year. How is the Canyon #1 with the worst consumer rating and quality rating? You nailed it on the Toyota stuff.I seem to have touched a nerve. You’re just proving my point about blind brand loyalty. ?
Let's examine the mid-size truck class for MY22 and look at their ability to do "truck things."
MY22 Truck Power / Torque Fuel Economy To 60 mph (C&D)** Max Payload Capacity Max Towing Capacity 4 Wheel Disc Brakes? Fully Boxed Frame? J.D. Power Quality & Reliability Score J.D. Power Verified Consumer Rating MotorTrend Mid-Size Rank C&D Rating Chevy Colorado 308 / 275 18.5 / 25 6.1s 1,543 lbs 7,000 lbs Yes Yes 82 83 #2 8.5 Ford Ranger 270 / 310 21 / 26 6.8s 1,905 lbs 7,500 lbs Yes Yes 85 83 #5 7 GMC Canyon 308 / 275 18.5 / 25 6.3s 1,578 lbs 7,000 lbs Yes Yes 79 82 #1 7 Jeep Gladiator 285 / 260 16.5 / 22.5 7.2s 1,700 lbs (4x4, BiC) 7,650 lbs Yes Yes 85 83 #4 8.5 Nissan Frontier 310 / 281 18 / 24 7.4s 1,610 lbs 6,720 lbs Yes Yes 83 83 #7 7.5 Toyota Tacoma 278 / 265 18 / 22 7.7s - 10.9s 1,685 lbs 6,800 lbs No No 81 82 #6 6.5
All numbers based on gasoline engine options.
** All 0-60 times based on Car & Driver reported times, except Ranger and Tacoma which could not be found on their website. The reported figures for Ranger and Tacoma come from Ford or Toyota affiliate (dealership) press materials. Different dealers reported different figures (7.7 and 10.9) for Tacoma. Honda Ridgeline (which is not really a truck) took #3 in Motortrend's mid-size truck ratings.
Tacoma is not best-in-class in a single metric, not even quality and reliability (where it comes in second-to-last), a metric on which the brand has built its reputation.
As far as reviews go, it is dead last in Car & Driver's ratings, and only above Nissan in MotorTrend's rankings (and the 2022 Nissan Frontier was the first year of a complete redesign). Words like "old" and "ancient" get thrown around in the MT and C&D reviews of the 2022 Tacoma.
It is toward the bottom of the class in power and torque, while also sitting toward the bottom of class in fuel economy, and being worst-in-class in the sprint to 60mph, owing to its horrible transmission. The transfer case hangs down below the frame rails.
It is second-to-last in towing capacity and middle of the pack in payload capacity.
It is the only mid-size truck (the Honda Ridgeline is not a truck) that still uses a C-channel in part of the chassis, where every other competitor is using a fully-boxed chassis.
It is the only mid-size truck without four-wheel disc brakes, and the brakes are spongey and grabby.
The only metric that Tacoma may hold over its competition is resale value, and I would say that Gladiator may end up giving it a run for its money, as Wranglers hold their value especially well.
The numbers don't lie... This is all the result of Toyota resting on its laurels, ignoring the marketplace, ignoring innovation, and refusing to stay current for fear of change, because change might impact reliability.
My mother in law insisted on buying a new Honda because “quality.” I told her to get out of 1980, lots of cars are great quality. People just blindly assume Honda and Toyota are the best cars on the road.
Sponsored