Not enough options as i think allot of us will use multiple tops or none at allWhat's going to be your main top?
If you get allot of snow you'll appreciate the hard top. I hate the hard top but in winter its so much easier to deal with than a soft top. snow and cold will shorten the life of your soft top in a hurry. I store mine in the summer on a shelf in the garage raised by a winch to the ceiling.Manual soft top during summer. Was going to go soft year round but I’m considering a hard top for winter now. Depends on how I like the look and whether I can find a place to store it in the summer.
Pete
It really depends on top quality. This is my 3rd NY winter and the top is still good as new, though the wrangler's besttop looks very thin and not much insulated if any at all. That's why MyTop is more insulated and quieter than the oem top, though at a much higher price.If you get allot of snow you'll appreciate the hard top. I hate the hard top but in winter its so much easier to deal with than a soft top. snow and cold will shorten the life of your soft top in a hurry. I store mine in the summer on a shelf in the garage raised by a winch to the ceiling.
May be so where you live but i'm in central Ontario and we get hit very hard in the winter. Soft tops are ok if you can park indoors all the time. I see allot of people around here with various soft tops that are destroyed after a couple winters. Even south of here around Toronto or Niagara you can get away with it but not here. I wish i could just run a soft top with a bikini for summer months.It really depends on top quality. This is my 3rd NY winter and the top is still good as new, though the wrangler's besttop looks very thin and not much insulated if any at all. That's why MyTop is more insulated and quieter than the oem top, though at a much higher price.