CantThinkOfAHandle
Well-Known Member
Oops, when I picked up my wagon in Munich, within a half hour I was driving 110 on the Autobahn. Then again, that was three years ago and it still runs perfectly.
Sponsored
I'm sure most engines will be fine, but you may have had one broken in on the dyno at the factory before it was even installed in the car. If you take 10 engines, run the hell out of them during break-in, and only one has a problem, I'd still say it isn't worth the risk. It will be at least a decade before I buy another new vehicle, so I'm just not taking a chance. I'm going to follow the manufacturer's break-in guidelines to the letter, at a minimum. I can wait to floor it until 300 miles, no problem.Oops, when I picked up my wagon in Munich, within a half hour I was driving 110 on the Autobahn. Then again, that was three years ago and it still runs perfectly.
My experience has been a vehicle will forever run like it is broken in. Run it hard right out of the gate. Otherwise expect a vehicle you can’t kick a dog in the ass with. Braking is different. Easy on braking for a few hundred miles.I'm sure most engines will be fine, but you may have had one broken in on the dyno at the factory before it was even installed in the car. If you take 10 engines, run the hell out of them during break-in, and only one has a problem, I'd still say it isn't worth the risk. It will be at least a decade before I buy another new vehicle, so I'm just not taking a chance. I'm going to follow the manufacturer's break-in guidelines to the letter, at a minimum. I can wait to floor it until 300 miles, no problem.
If that works for you. I've always followed the book and my engines have all run strong. They don't run strong if rings don't set properly. Sounds like your rings were already set.My experience has been a vehicle will forever run like it is broken in. Run it hard right out of the gate. Otherwise expect a vehicle you can’t kick a dog in the ass with. Braking is different. Easy on braking for a few hundred miles.
Which is still anecdotal evidence, and the least meaningful evidence when it comes to how many variables affect the longevity of an engine. I could say I only run my engines over 5k rpm on full moons, and they’ve lasted over 150k miles, therefore concluding that high rpm’s are safest during a full moon. I’m not singling just you out, but just using your post as an example. We can’t make sweeping generalizations amongst a myriad of changing variables and with such insignificant sample sizes.If that works for you. I've always followed the book and my engines have all run strong. They don't run strong if rings don't set properly. Sounds like your rings were already set.
Would you say that the factory break in procedure is based on anecdotal evidence? That's what I'm basing my practice upon. It is also based upon the advice and practice of engineers who design production and race engines. I was merely responding to someone who posted a belief that if you didn't flog an engine during break-in, it would run like a dog.Which is still anecdotal evidence, and the least meaningful evidence when it comes to how many variables affect the longevity of an engine. I could say I only run my engines over 5k rpm on full moons, and they’ve lasted over 150k miles, therefore concluding that high rpm’s are safest during a full moon. I’m not singling just you out, but just using your post as an example. We can’t make sweeping generalizations amongst a myriad of changing variables and with such insignificant sample sizes.
No no, not at all. I was simply saying that the best and most legitimate guide we have is the factory guide, which still has to be devised within a significant margin of error, and that people posting their own personal variations of the factory guide aren't really able to support them with anecdotal stories of long or short lasting engines.Would you say that the factory break in procedure is based on anecdotal evidence? That's what I'm basing my practice upon. It is also based upon the advice and practice of engineers who design production and race engines. I was merely responding to someone who posted a belief that if you didn't flog an engine during break-in, it would run like a dog.
Got it. That's what I've been basically saying all along. Look at the quote I responded to and you'll see the context.No no, not at all. I was simply saying that the best and most legitimate guide we have is the factory guide, which still has to be devised within a significant margin of error, and that people posting their own personal variations of the factory guide aren't really able to support them with anecdotal stories of long or short lasting engines.
Yep, we're good! Sorry for any confusion. I'm tired and easily misunderstand things or miscommunicate in that condition.Right, I wasn't trying to argue but rather just use your comment as a piggyback. That sounds strange but I think you know what I meant.
I hate driving through Atlanta. With a passion.I mapped out my route so it would include the Natchez Trace
Currently researching the mph 4000 rpms isI would highly recommend taking backroads in the first hundred miles of your drive home, and vary the throttle and load. Don't hot rod it, and stay under 4000 rpms for at least the first 500 miles and you should be good to go. 4000 rpms, according to Acura and Corvette engineers, is the point at which you cause problems with piston rings, if they are not seated. Also, long runs at the same rpm are bad. I'd start out on slower streets and back roads, then after 60 miles, go to faster back roads, then state highways, then after about 300 miles, I'd get on the interstate, but would NOT use cruise control. I'd continue to vary the speed between 55 and 75, or whatever the max is, until 500 miles. After 500, you should be good to light her up and do whatever you want. That plan would err on the side of caution, but would guarantee a proper break-in. Other than going over 4000rpm, droning down the highway at a constant speed would be the worst thing you can do to that engine in the first 300 miles.
Mine will get its first 60 miles right when I pick it up, and it will be city streets and country roads. I'll do that up to 100 miles. I'm not even going to shut it off until I hit 100 miles. I don't want to do a cold start until the ring seating is well under way.