Thank you. I guess my end goal is to protect the paint for now with the stock 33s, but then also upgrade to 35s on stock wheels when those tires wear out. Obviously continue to protect the paint at that time. Ideally, I’d like to make the purchase once, but don’t want to go XL and have it look goofy for 2 years.I'm running Nitto 295/70R17 Ridge Grapplers and rims with a 25 offset. That combo pushes me out 1 inch further than stock 33s and rims. I went with the RokBlokz XL to better cover that extra inch. I think you could get the coverage with the originals being effective on stock configuration. It's probably more a matter of what you visually like better. Why don't you check with RokBlokz if you can change flaps if you prefer a different size without any cost. There are pictures on their website showing the size differences. On mine, I know the original would not look as good and get full protection. Hope this helps.