I am about to revive the old thread but I got similar issue with my brand new Wrangler Sahara Unlimited. On the way back home from the dealership (my virgin trip) I noticed sort of rumbling around the windshield when I first hit 66 MPH. My first thought was the bug deflector but the bass sound is located close to me - I even have an impression I can feel the reverb on my steering wheel.I think I just figured this buffeting out, but want a couple people to give it a try first. I can re-create the buffeting by closing all the doors and windows and sitting in the backseat and pounding up on the inside of the hard top (inside my garage). I could hear a fluttering near the tailgate so I checked out the vents in tailgate. There are thin rubber flaps on the tailgate vents (behind the spare tire) that flutter when pounding from the inside. I had my wife pound the hardtop while I watched the rubber flaps move with each of her hits to the hard top. I pulled the rubber flaps off and the buffeting is gone. If someone else can give this a try to confirm that would be great. I believe the rubber flaps in the tailgate vent are there to keep dust out, but they must be sealing the air inside the Jeep cabin to well, causing the overpressure/buffeting only when all the doors and windows are closed.