This really does sum it up quite nicely. If you're not really going to tow anything it's a no-brainer for me, the Jeep 100%.I got rid of a full size truck to get a a JLUR. Couldn't be happier. Just think of all the places you and the family can go in a Jeep.
Personally, I prefer the interior cargo area as opposed to a bed on a pickup for road trips. Especially for a family of 4. Yeah you can put your stuff in the bed of the truck but if you don't have a topper, there's no 110% guarantee it will stay dry. (Although most bed covers these day do a decent job of minimizing water intrusion. The Jeep is more customizable. Insurance was cheaper for me on the Jeep compared to my 2016 Silverado that I bought new. I get better fuel economy in my Jeep loaded for a week of camping than I ever got in my truck with just a suitcase for a weekend trip. I don't know, just a few things that come to mind. But if you're dead set on getting a full size truck, look at the new RAM Rebels. I rented one recently and I was amazed at the offroadyness and comfort all wrapped in one.
If your wife had a Durango, then was there even a point to asking??Thanks for all the replies everyone! I think I’m going with the JLU! Especially since my wife has a Durango. The kids will love it too!

Thanks Maverick! And the kicker to all this is I can get a more expensive truck for cheaper than a Wrangler. But I think Wrangler it is. I don’t need the full-size.honestly i believe your debate is great. Truck or Jeep/SUV. ( ill get crap for that but its mid size family hauler. ive been in trucks my whole life. my old man always aid you cannot do any major projects without a truck to work out of. He was right. we are both very do it your self type of people. when i sold my daily driver P/U and picked up my JLU sport. it was a whole new world. the things i could no longer move or haul with my daily driver truck was hard to get used to. I have zero regrets on switching. if your not hauling anything or not towing to much then i say get the wrangler its a great vehicle and very joyful to drive.. thats my two cents
Great Compromise!Gladiator
just finished my build out:
