The Duratrac seems to rate better on tirerack at least initially but I've read that thye can get loud if not rotated often. I read through the reviews and both tires seem to have a lot of good reviews and I know the BFG seems to be well liked on here. Does the duratrac feel sloppy on the road compaired to the BFG? I plan on getting a new set of wheels and tires sometime between now and winter and my biggest concerns are traction as the tire wears, comfort, and driving on bad roads. My off roading will probably be fairly mild but the trails in my area tend to get pretty slippery when wet and I would like to have some confidence when I hit the mud.