Lol, I spent a TON of time trying to make that decision. I think I'd have been happy with any combo, but I do love the colored fenders. My wife made the final call on the black top because she said it looked more "Jeep" whereas the body colored top looked more "SUV."I'm really digging this, as I've been going back and forth on body color fenders vs black. Black roof definitely!
I ordered mine from HammerHead - it's the Zilla 11k Lumens LED Light. It's the one they recommended.