I'm having the same dilemma.
I'm going to go with MOPAR or Diode Dynamics. Much more functional design.
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08BZQM5NT/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_apa_fabc_iUdTFbQ8CW1SP
Alot of people dont want to loose the hardtop, for the 2 times a year it might be off...but we love having halfdoors Daily,
FYI,
Premium twill matches better with premium twill softop
Vinyl sailcloth matches better with painted black hardtop.
I will never give up the functionality / wiper...
Rhino Rack Backbone is the way to go.
Love it on my JK. RTT is great on it.
Will put on my JT.
Most people dont like the "huge cage" cost and commitment. Plus cages reduce so much / all the softop options. And noise / aero turbulence / MPG