I voted undecided. I kinda lean toward liking the JL better, but in terms of my next purchase, I kinda lean toward another JK at the moment for these monetary reasons:
The big (for my budget) bump in base price of the JL.
The assumption I won't be able to swap my extra set of factory half...
Not a fan of any variations of black/white/grey/silver.
I tend to like mostly non-metallic colors. My favorite colors from my brief time of Jeep (JK) ownership have been:
Cosmos Blue
Commando Green
Anvil
Flame Red (which I have)
Anything close to any of those would be most excellent.
For...
No cutout or clear half doors for me. Can't have anybody seeing all my kids' toys/books/snack leavings in the floor! :facepalm:
But seriously, half doors are awesome. I have a set for the front doors on my JKU (so far; looking for a rear set, too). Half doors with uppers out feels so much...
Some of the wheels we're seeing look close to the current JK Recon's wheels. I hope this means the bolt pattern's staying the same. (I have aftermarket wheels on my JKU I'd really like to swap over if I get into a JLU vs another JKU.)
How sweet would it be if you could do this to accommodate larger tires while keeping a stock(ish) look? Kinda like how JK guys sometimes chop their flares... but without the chopping part (and the application of weatherstripping or whatever to make it not look like crap).