Remember, it is called a Sport for a reason. That is because you are lighter weight.
Higher trim levels with the same engine may be better off-road, but not at the stop light.
Jeez! My two door weighs 3720 pounds. I'm a couple hundred pounds heavier than a Toyota Camry. It used to weigh 4200 pounds with all of that crap I was driving around with.
Where I live the most off roading I'm going to do is driving to the beach parking lot.
I actually like my Jeep now.
I have these. Compared to stock steel wheels feels like I went from riding around in army boots to ice skates
if that makes any sense. And gained 1.5 miles to the gallon.
My vote goes for General Grabbers A/TX.
Smoother, quieter, much more grip than the stock highway Michelin LTX tires that came on Jeep.
I have no idea how they where able to do this with an All terrain.