I went ahead and bought them. Love the look and weight of these. They are very substantial and add a good spot to step with grip. Look factory and the install was a breeze. I had a dealer coupon so got a great price.
I really like the stock wheels but ended up with AEV wheels as they are specifically designed for the JL and I was going for a blacked out look. Looking back, they were nice but the wider wheel and not having to go with spacers is worth it.